Sticker Set vs. Magnet Set: Which Decoration Wins?
By Fangamer - Video game shirts, plushes, books, and more. | Published: 2026-10-17
Category: Comparisons
Compare sticker sets and magnet sets for your gaming collection. We break down display options, durability, and cost to help you choose the right decoration.
Quick answer
Choose a sticker set if you want to decorate notebooks, laptops, or water bottles with kiss-cut, repositionable art. Choose a magnet set if you prefer a damage-free, swap-friendly display on metal surfaces like fridges or lockers. Both offer official game art, but magnets cost more and require a metal surface.
Display flexibility and surface compatibility
Stickers work on almost any clean, dry surface: paper, plastic, glass, metal, or painted walls. They are kiss-cut, meaning you peel the backing and stick them down permanently (or reposition carefully if fresh). Magnets, by contrast, only stick to ferromagnetic surfaces like refrigerators, filing cabinets, or magnetic boards. If your desk or wall is non-metal, you will need an extra magnetic sheet or board.
The New Friends Sticker Sheets Set 1 gives you three sheets of UNDERTALE-inspired art, each with multiple kiss-cut stickers. You can mix and match across surfaces or keep them on the backing sheet for storage. The After The Crash Lenticular Magnet Set offers six character magnets that shift between before-and-after crash designs, but they require a metal surface to hold.
Durability and longevity
Stickers are generally more durable outdoors or on items that get handled daily, because they are laminated and adhere directly. They resist moisture if applied to a sealed surface but can peel over time if edges lift. Magnets are solid objects that do not peel, but they can scratch or chip if dropped. Lenticular magnets like the After The Crash set have a moving image layer that is sensitive to scratches and direct sunlight.
If you plan to display your collection on a backpack or laptop that goes outside, stickers hold up better. For a static indoor display on a fridge or magnetic board, magnets last longer without wear.
Cost and value per piece
Sticker sets often give you more pieces for the price. The New Friends Sticker Sheets Set 1 costs $9.90 (compared to $15.00) and includes three sheets with multiple stickers each. The After The Crash Lenticular Magnet Set costs $16.50 (compared to $25.00) for six magnets. Per-item, stickers are usually more affordable, but magnets offer a physical, collectible feel that some fans prefer.
Consider how many surfaces you want to decorate and whether you value quantity or a premium display object.
Sticker vs. magnet: tradeoffs at a glance
- Surface compatibility: Stickers adhere to nearly any surface; magnets need metal. If your display area is a wooden desk or a plastic laptop, stickers win. For a fridge or magnetic board, magnets are cleaner. Check your intended surface before choosing.
- Reusability and flexibility: Magnets are fully reusable and easy to swap out. Stickers are permanent once applied, though you can reposition them briefly after first peel. If you like changing your display often, magnets are better. Magnets offer rearrangeability; stickers offer permanence.
- Cost per piece: Sticker sets give you more art for less money. The New Friends set costs $9.90 for three sheets; the After The Crash magnet set costs $16.50 for six magnets. If budget is tight, stickers stretch further. Stickers are the budget-friendly choice for quantity.
Product facts for comparison
- New Friends Sticker Sheets Set 1: Three sticker sheets' worth of your new neighbors in the Underground. Set 1 features three of the six kiss-cut sticker sheets needed to capture the whole UNDERTALE universe. Pick up both sets and save $2. You get multiple stickers per sheet, making this a cost-effective way to decorate many surfaces or share with a friend. Kiss-cut means you can peel and stick individually.
- After The Crash Lenticular Magnet Set: This official MOUTHWASHING magnet set shows six characters as they appear before and after the crash—Swansea, Daisuke, Anya, Curly, Jimmy, and Polle. They were designed by Nina Matsumoto; each one is about 1.5 inches tall. The lenticular design gives each magnet two looks, adding interactive fun. The 1.5-inch size is compact enough for a crowded fridge but still readable from a few feet away.
Which decoration fits you?
Best for
- Fans who want to decorate multiple surfaces like laptops, notebooks, and water bottles with affordable, durable art.
- Collectors who prefer a permanent, laminated decoration that can withstand outdoor use.
Not for
- Anyone who wants a damage-free, swap-friendly display on a fridge or locker—magnets are a better fit for that use case.
- Fans who need to display art on non-metal surfaces without adding a magnetic board.
